|
Istio Steering Committee
Thanks for all those thoughts Matt and for reviewing the steering committee proposal and GH issue https://github.com/cncf/toc/issues/459. I'm going to topline you here for brevity but LMK if you would
Thanks for all those thoughts Matt and for reviewing the steering committee proposal and GH issue https://github.com/cncf/toc/issues/459. I'm going to topline you here for brevity but LMK if you would
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5257
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
+1 for async comms For sync, I can't due any time after 10am PT due to family commitments.
+1 for async comms For sync, I can't due any time after 10am PT due to family commitments.
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5254
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
I'm keen to discuss this in the TOC, and then work out details in the various WGs and community. When is everyone back?
I'm keen to discuss this in the TOC, and then work out details in the various WGs and community. When is everyone back?
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5250
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
Agree. The underlying issues are set out here https://docs.google.com/document/d/11Hiz1dGYRS7GcjedpRVnSlDjIj0AVjeTa0-Td7aW-Lk/edit?usp=drivesdk
Agree. The underlying issues are set out here https://docs.google.com/document/d/11Hiz1dGYRS7GcjedpRVnSlDjIj0AVjeTa0-Td7aW-Lk/edit?usp=drivesdk
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5239
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
Nobody is suggesting imposing anything. That suggestion is a red herring.
Nobody is suggesting imposing anything. That suggestion is a red herring.
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5236
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
Agree that SC should (if suggested) remain a known good option, and Not Compulsory. Agree that some projects are "small" - but i would have said Helm is small! My belief is that SCs can help growth. M
Agree that SC should (if suggested) remain a known good option, and Not Compulsory. Agree that some projects are "small" - but i would have said Helm is small! My belief is that SCs can help growth. M
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5234
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
I think you are creating a strawman argument. We are not substituting one form of governance for another. The issue is how SCs can add value eg direction, participation, and user confidence that featu
I think you are creating a strawman argument. We are not substituting one form of governance for another. The issue is how SCs can add value eg direction, participation, and user confidence that featu
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5232
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
Josh, please disentangle your feelings about istio from the constructive discussion i can see you want to have.
Josh, please disentangle your feelings about istio from the constructive discussion i can see you want to have.
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5230
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
It isn't but it has aspects we can learn from (good and bad) as do other projects (eg apache kafka to name one). This thread is specifically about steering committees, and what they can help with espe
It isn't but it has aspects we can learn from (good and bad) as do other projects (eg apache kafka to name one). This thread is specifically about steering committees, and what they can help with espe
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5227
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
Josh, feel free to highlight the negative aspects of Istio's history and governance on another thread. I may well join you. But please let's also give them credit for moving forward with improvements.
Josh, feel free to highlight the negative aspects of Istio's history and governance on another thread. I may well join you. But please let's also give them credit for moving forward with improvements.
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5225
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
Good points Matt. Helm is well run and provides a useful model of one successful pattern. I don't think there is one true governance rule for who is on the SC. IMHO it is critical to include non code
Good points Matt. Helm is well run and provides a useful model of one successful pattern. I don't think there is one true governance rule for who is on the SC. IMHO it is critical to include non code
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5221
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
Good comments Joe. I also don't adore every aspect of the Istio model. eg I agree that "credit for contributions accrue to companies, not individuals" isn't optimal. But I still like what they are try
Good comments Joe. I also don't adore every aspect of the Istio model. eg I agree that "credit for contributions accrue to companies, not individuals" isn't optimal. But I still like what they are try
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5218
·
|
|
Istio Steering Committee
Hi TOC community I saw this news and wanted to highlight it. With kubecon behind us and apparently summer too, perhaps we can revisit the Steering Committee thread. https://twitter.com/DanCiruli/statu
Hi TOC community I saw this news and wanted to highlight it. With kubecon behind us and apparently summer too, perhaps we can revisit the Steering Committee thread. https://twitter.com/DanCiruli/statu
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5215
·
|
|
[RESULT] k3s accepted into Sandbox
congratulations and thank you all for the respectful discussion on this complex topic
congratulations and thank you all for the respectful discussion on this complex topic
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5203
·
|
|
[EXTERNAL] Re: [cncf-toc] [VOTE] TiKV Graduation
+1 nb <bburns=microsoft.com@...> wrote:
+1 nb <bburns=microsoft.com@...> wrote:
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5193
·
|
|
[VOTE] k3s for Sandbox
Currently k3s is a distro of k8s. We used to have a k8s sandbox. If we still did then k3s would happily live there as a way to show k8s how to be a better project.
Currently k3s is a distro of k8s. We used to have a k8s sandbox. If we still did then k3s would happily live there as a way to show k8s how to be a better project.
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5102
·
|
|
[VOTE] k3s for Sandbox
-1, nb +1 to joe & bob comments. I am very keen to see k3s initiative do well I am even more keen to see it feed back into K8s let's find a way to make this work! I don't know the answer and recognise
-1, nb +1 to joe & bob comments. I am very keen to see k3s initiative do well I am even more keen to see it feed back into K8s let's find a way to make this work! I don't know the answer and recognise
|
By
alexis richardson
· #5098
·
|
|
[VOTE] Cortex for Incubation
+1 nb
By
alexis richardson
· #5074
·
|
|
Proposal for a new "Steering Committee Charter"
Matt Thank you for the feedback and for reviewing the proposal. I agree that the doc is light on continuity details. We have a lot of prior art on projects that face growth challenges but very little
Matt Thank you for the feedback and for reviewing the proposal. I agree that the doc is light on continuity details. We have a lot of prior art on projects that face growth challenges but very little
|
By
alexis richardson
· #4984
·
|
|
Proposal for a new "Steering Committee Charter"
Folks The issue we are facing here is how to make projects, and hence the cncf, sustainable. As Quinton pointed out this requires incentives. Marketing buzz is short lived and sponsors will move on to
Folks The issue we are facing here is how to make projects, and hence the cncf, sustainable. As Quinton pointed out this requires incentives. Marketing buzz is short lived and sponsors will move on to
|
By
alexis richardson
· #4955
·
|