Public comment is extended through May 25th due to KubeCon, the vote will open then.-- Amye Scavarda Perrin | Director of Developer Programs, CNCF | amye@...

+1 From:cncf-toc@... <cncf-toc@...> on behalf of alexis richardson via lists.cncf.io <alexis=weave.works@...> Date: Thursday, 5. May 2022 at 18:30 To: Liz Rice <liz@...> Cc: Alexis Richardson via

Hi TOC, The TAG Security Co-chairs would like to nominate Ragashree, Michael Lieberman, and Marina Moore as Technical Leads of TAG Security! They have been awesome members of the community

There is a different sandbox logo, and projects are required to explicitly say they are sandbox whenever they mention that they are CNCF projects. The staff are pretty good at chasing up if folks

We need VCs to sit on their hands until Incubation

Just for a historic perspective. When we did this discussion the last time, we identified that there are fundamentally two divergent goals that we have to balance: Projects Goal #1) Bring multiple,

Hello there! I’d like to report that a PR for the SMI sandbox project’s annual review has been submitted: https://github.com/cncf/toc/pull/833. Please review at your earliest convenience.

Remember, the point of cncf is not to create ways for committees to sit in judgment over projects. It is to make great projects that enable end user success. That is all.

Four levels would increase the total work required to assess a project through their life cycle. There might be good reasons to do it, but I don't see that it would solve the initial problem raised on

Stringent implies work, judgement, and value. It seems that scaling wall has been hit already..

I agree on quite a few points :) Replying in line with some thoughts > We tried SIGs (now TAGs) doing due diligence for projects. The level> of scrutiny, and the closeness to the guidance material

Which parts, specifically? I think we need consensus on a direction before we, potentially, start new/updating processes. Agreed. At the same time, we need to take Goodhart's law[1] into account. A

Richard how would you formalise this? The goal, IMO, is to reduce the subjective judgment on entry to sandbox, and increase the quantitative aspects

Replying top-level as my thoughts jump across the thread. I didn't run the numbers, yet I believe that the pace of submissions has picked up. That alone can increase backlog. We tried SIGs (now

Hello everyone! Just a reminder that the cutoff for making project proposals is May 8th! This is a great opportunity to have a paid mentee help with your projects. Please open a PR with your ideas:

+ 1 NB -- Thanks and Regards, Maulik Shyani CEO 408.480.8501

+1 NB Chris Short He/Him/His Sr. Developer Advocate, AWS Kubernetes (GitOps) TZ=America/Detroit

Got it - thank you!

Katie, typically whoever makes it to the event in-person :)-- Davanum Srinivas :: https://twitter.com/dims

Hello Dawn - thanks a lot for your direction here. We will surely work on the given resources. --