I share Camille’s concern. Note that the only explicit requirement in this regard w.r.t. Incubation level is as follows (from https://www.cncf.io/projects/graduation-criteria/): Document that it is

Basically, I'm concerned that there are not really actual production users who also are project committers that aren't YouTube/Google.

But it is not yet in prod? Bringing it to prod sounds like not.

Just got this confirmation from Hubspot: "Definitely using. Two dedicated full timers working on bringing it to prod. Three others supporting part time, plus me. We have a handful of prod clusters at

I'm confused, is hubspot using or evaluating this product? The different slide decks seem to disagree.

+1 (binding) - Bryan

Hey everyone, I'm happy to announce that rook has been accepted into CNCF as an INCEPTION level project (sponsored by Ben Hindman): https://github.com/cncf/toc/pull/57 +1 TOC binding votes (6 / 9): -

Hi everyone Thank-you for a very well attended and productive TOC call on Jan 16th. The next call is on Feb 6th, in eight days time. This is a call for Agenda items from the TOC community. I

+1 (non-binding)

+1 non-binding

+1 non-binding

Trying again: +1 binding

Trying again: +1 binding

+1 non-binding ------------------ Nathan Xu Shenzhen Wise2c technology Co.,ltd ------------------ Original ------------------ From: "Chris Aniszczyk"<caniszczyk@...>; Date: Fri, Jan 26, 2018 00:50

+1 (non-binding)

+1 non-binding

+1 binding

+1 (non-binding)

+1 non binding

+1 non-binding