Just recapping the current vote for record keeping purposes. Binding TOC votes: +1 Ben Hindman: http://lists.cncf.io/pipermail/cncf-toc/2016-May/000196.html +1 Ken Owens: http://lists.cncf.io/pipermail/cncf-toc/2016-May/000197.html +1 Jonathan Boulle: http://lists.cncf.io/pipermail/cncf-toc/2016-May/000199.html +1 Camille Fournier: http://lists.cncf.io/pipermail/cncf-toc/2016-May/000200.html +1 Brian Grant: http://lists.cncf.io/pipermail/cncf-toc/2016-May/000201.html Non-binding community votes: +1 Sarah Saul: http://lists.cncf.io/pipermail/cncf-toc/2016-May/000202.html On Mon, May 9, 2016 12:55 PM, Alexis Richardson alexis@... wrote: Sarah Please could you summarise the votes to date. a On Mon, May 9, 2016 at 8:39 PM, Sarah Saul via cncf-toc <cncf-toc@...> wrote: Hello TOC members, Friendly reminder to vote on the “incubation principle” if you haven't already done so. We have 5 out of the 9 TOC votes. +1 (non binding) Best, Sarah On Fri, May 6, 2016 11:08 AM, Brian Grant via cncf-toc cncf-toc@... wrote: YES On Thu, May 5, 2016 at 1:09 PM, Alexis Richardson via cncf-toc <cncf-toc@...> wrote: TOC voters, Per our call this week, we wish to record support for the “incubation principle” via a vote on a formal statement. Please indicate your vote on when a project is promoted from Incubation by saying YES or NO. Today we are seeking unanimous support, from all TOC voting members, for the following statement. If this vote is passed then we shall record the principle in appropriate venues such as the CNCF development process (which is still being worked out).  alexis ---- “1. The time when becoming a CNCF Project is irrevocable is when a project is promoted from Incubation 2. Prior to this a project may choose to leave, or be asked to leave. The TOC might change this rule in the future but for now it has a clear rationale: it enables new projects to have a safety valve. Before the TOC has finalised its modus operandi and how we help CNCF projects, we want projects to join CNCF and help us shape our model. So we are asking projects to join despite this uncertainty. In return we provide a safety valve.” ---- FYI: Stemmed from the April 13th discussion: http://lists.cncf.io/pipermail/cncf-toc/2016-April/000131.html _______________________________________________ cncf-toc mailing list cncf-toc@... https://lists.cncf.io/mailman/listinfo/cncf-toc Sarah Saul Client Services Manager The Linux Foundation (M) 520-245-5185 Skype: srsaul _______________________________________________ cncf-toc mailing list cncf-toc@... https://lists.cncf.io/mailman/listinfo/cncf-toc Sarah Saul Client Services Manager The Linux Foundation (M) 520-245-5185 Skype: srsaul