New Idea proposal vetting - adding hook logs output


bez625@...
 

Hi all,

It's been well over a month since we addressed Matt's feedback on the PR and we've tried to make contact multiple times via the github review, slack and this mailing list all of which have been completely ignored.... Is there something more we need to be doing to get this reviewed? Or at least acknowledged?

Thanks
Chris 


bez625@...
 

Hi all,

We have been waiting for some time now without response - is there anything we can do to progress this PR?

I believe there is appetite for this feature in the community too so it would be good if we could at least get an update...

Thanks
Chris 


bez625@...
 

Thanks very much to Matt for giving us feedback on this - we have addressed his feedback and added docs and testing to give everyone a better idea of what this would like like.

If we could get the PR reviewed that would be very much appreciated https://github.com/helm/helm/pull/10309

Thanks!
Chris 


bez625@...
 

Hello all,
 
As suggested by the contributing docs we are trying to vet a new feature idea with the community. 
 
The idea is to add configurable outputting of logs from hook jobs and pods on failure - addressing issues #3481 and #2298.
 
We have raised a PR as a working proof of concept and have been trying to get some feedback from the maintainers: https://github.com/helm/helm/pull/10309
 
We have been asking on Kubernetes #helm-dev channel for feedback, but haven't got any response yet. We don't really want to put more work in to this, e.g. docs and testing, if the idea will be rejected outright. 
 
Thanks for your time
Chris